The Lost Story by Meg Shaffer

I love a book with a playlist, and The Lost Story comes with one. It’s also a modern-day fairy tale, filled with magic, mystery, and the impossible.

As teens, Ralph (Rafe) and Jeremy get lost in the Red Crow forest of West Virginia and are gone for months. Rafe has no memory of what happened, where they were, or how they got home. Jeremy grows up to be world-renowned for his ability to find lost girls and women.

Years later, Emilie loses her mother to cancer and learns about a sister she never knew existed, a girl who was abducted and missing for years. Alone and mourning, Emilie tracks down Jeremy and begs him to help find Shannon. But when he learns Shannon went missing in Red Crow, he refuses to get involved… at least initially.

What worked: This is about more than a search and rescue. It’s love found, lost, and rediscovered, and family unknown yet somehow missed in an inexplicable way. The lies and truths are equally painful, and they must be known in order to heal, move forward, and resolve so many wrongs, even if there’s no way to fix what was broken. It’s whimsical yet serious, humorous and honest.

The banter between Justin and Emilie is such an underrated thing in writing. From their first meeting, they interact like siblings: sassy, sarcastic quips that you know are darts padded with cotton to be glancing blows instead of wounds. And I’m still chuckling about Emilie’s fierce reaction to Rafe punching Jeremy! The dialogue and scene-setting are well done, and the story is vivid and detailed enough that I could easily envision it on the screen, though the book will undoubtedly be better.

There’s also a pet rat and a nod to The Last Unicorn. My sister Michelle loves animals of all varieties, and I know she’d delight in Emilie’s pet rat. As kids, she collected unicorns. We watched The Last Unicorn countless times, and we will sometimes still sing out, “I’m alive!”

I never appreciated magic as a child, at least not in the way I do as an adult. Day after day, we are faced with reality, practicality, inevitability. Magic, if only for the shortest of moments, can add a spark of hope. I really enjoy stories that infuse a little magic into the mundane and ordinary. After all, who are we to say magic doesn’t exist? I also appreciated the quiet reference to Shaffer’s debut novel, The Wishing Game.

What didn’t: My analytical mind picked up on a loophole in the “rules” of returning to the world of Shannondoah. It’s still poking at my thoughts, but it isn’t enough to dampen my enjoyment of the book on the whole.

Who it’s for: Readers who like a little magic in the everyday and a story that’s whimsical and serious at once, especially fans of The Ocean at the End of the Lane, Old Flames and New Fortunes, and A Novel Love Story.

Get The Lost Story on Bookshop.org

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through my Bookshop.org link, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you, and your purchase supports independent bookstores.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.